[Buyer’s Guide] The Best SIG P238 Holsters of 2019

The SIG P238 is a compact and small handgun, intentionally built for concealment. The P238 is an amazing choice of a concealed carry firearm for daily use. But eventually, carrying a firearm requires a good and reliable holster.

With a plethora of options available on the market, choosing the right fit for your needs might be a tedious task sometimes.

To help you get rid of this problem, this article talks about some essential qualities to be seen before choosing a holster for your SIG P238. Additionally, we have also searched and reviewed the best holsters for the SIG P238 available on the market.

Comparison Chart of the Best SIG P238 Holster

PRODUCT
gm2-table__image

Desantis Nemesis SIG P238 Ambidextrous Pocket Holster

  • Ambidextrous design
  • Made from high-quality Nylon
  • Great fit for P238 SIG Sauer pistols
View Latest Price
gm2-table__image

Concealment Express IWB Kydex Holster

  • IWB design
  • Made from high-quality Kydex
  • Available in right-hand or left-hand orientation
View Latest Price
gm2-table__image

Cya Supply Co. IWB Holster

  • Made from high-quality materials
  • Clip made from steel and designed for stable holding
  • Secure lock feature to keep the pistol in place and prevent slippage
View Latest Price
gm2-table__image

Ankle Holster For Concealed Carry

  • Available for both hand orientations
  • Best holster for ankle concealed carry
  • Fits measurements between 8 to 13 inches
View Latest Price

Benefits of Investing in a Quality SIG P238 Holster

If you are looking to get a few benefits out of a holster for a SIG P238, then you’re in the right place. These holsters are perfect for your pistol regardless if you are carrying it every day or while you are at the range and using it for safekeeping your pistol. Here are some benefits you’ll get to enjoy:

Excellent For Concealed/EDC Carry

Preparation matters most. That is an undeniable fact. And if you do practice concealed carry, you are required to utilize a holster even if you are carrying a pistol in public. It’s better to be ready for any dangers that may threaten your life or property no matter where you are. So if you need a pistol close by, then a holster will be exactly what you need. Plus it saves you time from running from one place to where you are storing your pistol, which might be risky to do if you are in a life and death situation. 

Good Enough to Last You a Long Time

This will depend on the holster’s material. And for the most part, the materials will be high in quality. Whether it’s nylon, leather, or Kydex, you’ll want quality materials built to last, that won’t allow for any tearing or snagging. Every holster should be sturdy enough to ensure that your pistol will be kept safe and secure with no wiggle room to speak of. 

A Guaranteed Fit Every Time

Each holster is measured to fit perfectly with your pistol. They won’t be too small or too big. If you are looking for a holster that will fit like a glove, then you’ll find that all five of these holsters will give you that benefit. And you won’t need to make any adjustments or have to struggle with the fitting aspect of a holster.

Are All SIG P238 Holsters the Same?

Absolutely, not. The case with holsters is just the same as any other product. Holsters differ in material, design, level of concealment, and several other factors.

Apart from that, there are certain specific qualities which make some P238 holsters stand apart from others. Let's take a look at a few of them:

The first and foremost feature is the wardrobe. There are several different styles of holsters used for carrying and concealment.

These include ankle holsters, IWB (Inside Waistband), OWB (Outside Waistband), Shoulder Straps, pocket holsters and gun belts.

Each of them has their own pros and cons. Shoulder straps, for example, allow you to carry two extra mags, but the position of your holster poses a threat to people behind or beside you.

Other important features are the adjustable cant and locking mechanism for retention. Several holsters provide an adjustable cant feature which allows you to angle your holster at your desired position while it is attached to your belt.

Adjustable Cant Visual (source)

Several holsters feature a locking mechanism like the ALS, the SERPA or the retention screw to prevent the gun from falling out of the holster, and providing a secure storage for your SIG P238.

Apart from these, some holsters are made up of kydex or simple polymer material, which are not very comfortable when carrying or sitting. When it comes to comfort, leather or hybrid material holsters are the best.

What Makes a Great SIG P238 Holster?

There are a few qualities that make a great P238 holster. We have segregated and reviewed the products based on these qualities, which make a P238 holster ideal.

Concealment

The P238 is a small and compact firearm, designed intentionally to act as a concealed weapon. A good P238 holster must serve this purpose precisely. You don’t want your holster to outline itself over your shirt or T-shirt making people anxious around you.

Covering the Trigger Guard

A good P238 holster, must, at all times, cover the trigger guard of the handgun. There are holsters around the market which don’t do this, and you should avoid them.

The reason is that an exposed trigger guard might catch onto something and accidentally fire your weapon. Additionally, when you draw your weapon, there are chances that your finger might get stuck over the trigger resulting in accidental discharge.

Comfort

A good P238 holster must offer comfort to the bearer. Choose wisely the material of the holster, and the paddle so it doesn’t bruise your skin or make you feel uncomfortable.

Retention and Wobble

A great P238 holster must offer reliable retention and a quick and safe draw for your weapon. Additionally, a holster must fit close to your body and must not wobble much as you move.

Quick Take - The Best SIG P238 Holsters

Review of the Best SIG P238 Holsters

The following is a list of the five best SIG P238 Holsters that are currently on the market. As you look through each one, it is important that you jot down any of the interesting features and characteristics that stand out. If you are looking for an “ideal holster”, you may want to consider your notes to ensure that you find one that is close enough to your ideal description. Remember, close enough is better than nothing. Now, let’s begin by taking a look at the first holster on the list:

Now we're going to move onto the review portion of our article and take a look at some of our top picks. We're going to explain each holster's main features, as well as some common pros and cons. Let's get started.

DeSantis Nemesis Sig P238 Ambidextrous Black

Pros

  • Durable construction
  • Excellent for left-handed shooters
  • Provides maximum concealability
  • Holds up pretty good on most waistbands or belts
  • Ambidextrous
  • Comfortable Fabric
  • Fits the P238 like a glove
  • It Has a Slick Pack-Cloth Inside

Cons

  • Some experienced snagging in certain orientations
  • Nylon stitching on the edges can be rough until it wears in
  • No Paddle Or Belt Attachments
  • No Retention or Locking Mechanism

What Recent Buyers Report 

Most buyers were satisfied with the holster. They intended to use this holster for the purpose of maximizing their concealability. And they were quite successful in doing so. This was a great fit overall for hip and pocket carrying. One user, in particular, was quite satisfied with the durable construction of the holster and was confident in its abilities in keeping the pistol in place.

Why it Stands Out to Us 

This holster is designed to make concealability as excellent as possible. By that, we mean making sure you are still carrying your pistol even without a single hint of bulging that may occur with some holsters that are considered IWB designed. The material made for this is a sturdy type of cloth material that will keep the pistol dust-free while it keeps it nice and secure when the pistol is fitted inside. No wiggle room will be non-existent and you’ll have a clean, quick draw each and every time. 

The Desantis Nemesis pocket holster features a nylon material construction and fits the P238 like a glove. The holster can fit inside either of your pant or jacket pockets and protects your P238 from scratches.

The material of the holster is viscous and breathable offering comfort to the bearer. The holster is a bit sticky like fly paper, so it doesn’t move much around your pocket.

The foam does not break up the outline of the gun, offering high concealment. The holster doesn’t have any retention mechanism or locks, but the gun still fits snug and holds its place.

Why it Stands Out to Us 

This would be excellent for those who are in search of a holster that will get the job done in terms of concealability. It may fit in your pocket or inside your waistband, but regardless it will be easy for you to conceal your SIG P238 in this holster without drawing any undue attention. Listen, people might feel uncomfortable being around those who conceal carry (but that’s more of their personal issue than it is yours). But you are ready for any danger that may threaten you or those around you. This holster will help you prepare for that.

Bottom Line

The Desantis Nemesis is surprisingly one of the best holsters you can find for a SIG P238 when it comes to concealability. Fit this in your pocket or on your waistband and you’ll get a good amount of security and fuss-free concealing out of the whole deal. It holds up pretty good and is quite durable for the most part.

The Nemesis holster is a lightweight and sleek cover for your P238. It is often good for carrying your handgun in your pockets or purse. It is less of a holster and more of a cover for concealing and protecting your P238. However, it is still easy to carry.

Best SIG P238 IWB Holster:
Concealment Express IWB Kydex Holster

Pros

  • Super comfortable fit
  • Very durable Kydex construction
  • Provides excellent concealment for your pistol
  • Doesn’t slip when attached to waistbands or belts
  • Lightweight and Secure
  • Full-Length Sweat Guard
  • Trigger Guard Stays Covered
  • Adjustable Cant and Retention
  • Unconditional Lifetime Warranty

Cons

  • Might be too high of a fit for some waistbands
  • A few have reported the belt being a little too loose
  • Some complain about it not having a large enough sweat shield
  • Kydex Might Feel Uncomfortable While You Sit

What Recent Buyers Report 

A lot of new users were quite happy with the overall fit and durability of the holster. Not to be outdone, they were quite satisfied with the secure fit and were able to draw their pistols out of the holster quickly without any kind of snagging to speak of. As for the ability to conceal their pistols, they were able to carry them without any discomfort or bulging. They said that the amount of undue attention they’ve received for carrying their pistols was pretty much nowhere to be found. 

Why it Stands Out to Us 

This holster is another one that will pretty much guarantee maximum concealability. The only difference is that it is made with some pretty serious material that won’t even wear or tear. Yes, Kydex has grown in popularity over a few years. And it might be on par with polymer as far as durability and quality is concerned. It is sturdy enough to handle your pistol for the purpose of EDC carry, so you are prepared for the danger that might lay ahead. If you are in a life-threatening situation you’re going to need to use your pistol (although it might never come down to that anyway). But being prepared is better than never at all. And this bad boy is sturdy and easy on the skin. No wonder why it’s considered to be one of the best IWB holsters for a SIG P238. 

This holster from Concealment Express features a molded kydex body which offers a pre-formed mold to hold your P238. It is an IWB (Inside Waistband) type holster which features a retention tightening screw to adjust the amount of friction for your draw.

The carry angle can also be adjusted between a range of 0 to 15 degrees. The standard ABS plastic belt clip can be attached to belts of 1.5 inches in width. The trigger guard stays covered in this holster and the ‘click’ audible retention lock system helps in ensuring security.

Who Will Use This Most

This will definitely be the go-to choice for those who want something tough, long-lasting, and awesome for maximum concealability. It’s the holster that won’t cause any grief and make any EDC carry application as comfortable and easy as possible. No skin irritation, no bulging, no problem. This holster will be a blessing to many concealed carry users out there if they are either getting sick and tired of their old, unreliable holster or getting something that might be newbie-friendly. 

Bottom Line

The Concealment Express IWB Kydex Holster is probably one of the go-to choices for you if you’re in search of a really comfortable and super durable holster for a SIG P238. If your other holster has been giving you grief, you know its time for an upgrade. This holster, in particular, might just be right up your alley if durability and concealability are two of your best “make or break” conditions in making your final purchasing decision.

It is a perfect holster for carrying your P238. The IWB design helps with the concealment and the locking plus ‘click’ mechanism makes its use secure.

The adjustable cant and retention offer you the choice to use it the way you want. Integrated sweat guard adds comfort, but kydex might feel annoying when you fit, or if you are skinny.

Best SIG Sauer P238 Concealed Carry Holster:
Cya Supply Co. IWB Holster

CYA Supply Co. IWB Holster Veteran Owned Company

Pros

  • Quick and easy drawing
  • Affordable for most budgets
  • Comfortable fit for most users
  • Superior durability. Wear and tear is minimal
  • Excellent security. Doesn’t allow the holster to wiggle around and slip out
  • Easy to Grip
  • IWB Design Promotes Concealment
  • Posi Click Audible Retention System
  • Adjustable Retention and Cant Mechanism

Cons

  • Edges can be a bit smoother
  • Clip has failed on some owners
  • Some report it riding a bit higher than expected
  • Right Hand Draw Only
  • Holster Outline Might Feel Uncomfortable While Sitting

What Recent Buyers Report

A lot of new users had no problems with this holster at all. Even better, they were looking for something that was high in quality and performance but affordable for most budgets. They got more than what they’ve paid for with this holster. The comfort was outstanding and no irritation was said to be reported. Even one user said that he loved wearing this holster for concealed carry much better than his OWB holster that he had owned for more than a decade. 

Why It Stands Out To Us

If you are looking for the best holster for the money, then you’ve got one right here. Made from high-quality materials? Check. Fits SIG P238 pistols? Check. Superior comfort and concealability? Double-check on both counts. This holster is perfect for even many concealed carry users that are looking for a budget-friendly solution. The security lock feature is where it makes its money. It can prevent those from trying to access your gun other than yourself. And that alone will prevent any kind of accidental discharges or misuse from happening. If safety is paramount in a holster, this might be the best holster you’ll find.

The CYK Supply Co. Holster is an IWB type holster made from Boltaron material, which is similar to kydex. The holster can be clipped on to the belt,  and the retention friction and the cant can both be adjusted using an Allen key provided with the package.

The sweat guard covers full-length of side and the posi click audible retention system makes you aware when the gun was locked. The holster clips on tight to the belt, preventing any wiggle.

The trigger guard remains covered which is good and safe. Though the thermoplastic material might not feel very comfortable on the inside due to the outline on the outside, it is still a matter of personal choice.

 

Who Would Use This Most?

This will be a great holster for those looking for an affordable solution. And it might be the perfect price for those looking for a starter holster. If you are a concealed carry newbie and don’t want to spend an arm and a leg on a holster, this just might be one of your best possible options. Don’t be surprised if this winds up being the only holster you’ll rely on in the years down the road. It won’t fall apart in terms of quality and has the potential to hold your pistol in place for a long time. It ain’t cheap and flimsy in the slightest. But for the price it’s going for, this sucker might just be worth twice as much as you’ll be paying. 

Bottom Line

The CYA Supply Co. IWB Concealed Carry Holster is available for many concealed carry users at a pretty reasonable price. If you want maximum concealability and reliable carrying without having to break the bank, this holster is the clear choice for you. You’ll get something that will hold up quite nicely and will ensure that you’ll be ready to use your pistol for whatever application you intend to use it for. 

The CYA Supply Co. Holster is an exception IWB holster for your P238. It is a veteran owned company, and the service is excellent. The holster is rightly priced, offers concealment, and has adjustable cant, and retention mechanism. The holster is overall a good choice for a person with a decent budget.

Ankle Holster for Law Enforcement, Military, Personal Protection and Concealed Carry | B.U.G Leg Holster | Fits: Glock 43, 42, 33, 30, 27, 26 M&P Shield 9mm, Bodyguard .380, Ruger LCP, LC9, Sig Sauer

Pros

  • Affordable for most budgets
  • Excellent security and durability
  • Fits quite comfortably around the ankles
  • Perfect for concealed carry in cold weather
  • Suitable for some occupations like security
  • Pocket For Extra Mag
  • One Size Fits All Design
  • Comfortable Anti-Slip Fabric
  • Lightweight and Ambidextrous
  • Velcro Strap Adjustable Retention

Cons

  • Finding the ideal level of tight, but not too tight is tough
  • Long Draw Time
  • Not Fit For People With Very Large Calves

What Recent Buyers Report 

Most of the new users were quite happy with the holster since it allowed for quick discreet drawing. At the same time, it was perfect for those who were looking for a holster that achieved maximum concealability. For most users, the fit was snug and comfortable and was perfect for those working security or needed a concealed carry holster to keep their pistols warm in colder temperatures. One user said that he was satisfied with the fact that this holster was able to fit his ankle properly without undoing itself. 

Why it Stands Out to Us 

Ankle holsters are quite unique (or for that matter, any kind of holster). But these types of holsters are often available to those who are not only looking for discreet, maximum concealability but for those who want to be clever with drawing their pistols if and when danger seems to be lurking by. Only a fool who dares attack you would expect you to draw from your hip. But if you want to be steps ahead of an assailant, this holster might just be what you need for discreet, no bulge carrying. 

The ankle is probably not a very popular point to holster a handgun. But still, there are people out there who need ankle holsters. They come in handy when you want to carry a gun in such a way, that it does not meddle with your everyday life. This ankle holster lets you forget that you are wearing a gun.

It's made from breathable neoprene fabric which sits soft and is comfortable on the skin. The velcro straps help in adjusting the ‘one-size-fits-all’ design of this holster. It also features an additional compartment to hold an extra mag.

The bonus retention strap helps in securing the holster tightly for added peace of mind. This holster can hold most guns and has an ambidextrous design to use with either right or left leg. Good for keeping a backup handgun.

Who Will Use This Most 

This holster might just be exactly what you are looking for if you need something for your profession (i.e.--security) or if you need a holster other than what you might be wearing on your hip. Ankle carry might just be one of the last things many people will expect from those who conceal carry. And that’s probably a good thing. Sometimes it’s good to be creative while being prepared. If you want an ankle holster that fits snug and keeps the pistol intact whenever you need it, this might be right up your alley. 

Bottom Line

If you want a durable, well-fit holster that will make concealed carry interesting, this ankle holster from Bear Armz Tactical just might be exactly what you are looking for. It’s durable, easy to fit, and will certainly be one of the best choices for a pistol like a SIG P238. It’s comfortable and it won’t feel like you’re dragging around a ball and chain when you have the pistol in place. 

The Ankle Holster is a perfect solution if you want to forget the adjustments to your P238 holster while you carry it. This holster is soft and comfortable and allows you to carry an extra mag. The draw times with this design are higher, but it is still a good fit for keeping a backup weapon.

XCH Smith & Wesson M&P Compact, M&P Shield, Sig Sauer P238/P938, Colt Defender Shoulder gun holster

Pros

  • Excellent durability
  • Super comfortable to wear
  • Provides great concealability
  • Easy to fit for most shooter frames and sizes
  • Perfect for cold weather carry or for security guards on duty
  • Good Finish
  • Doesn’t Wobble
  • Adjustable Barrel Direction
  • Detachable Magazine Holder

Cons

  • May be tough to adjust at first
  • Some say it might be a little too thin
  • Very tall owners found it a little snug
  • Might Feel Congested On the Underarms

What Recent Buyers Report

As expected, a lot of new users had no complaints about this shoulder holster. Most of them were either working professional security or using it for cold weather concealability. The holster’s durability was never questioned and proved itself to be really tough each time it was being used. The adjustments were made to ensure it was a perfect fit for most users ranging from some shorter to some above-average heights. One user said that it was a perfect, comfortable fit that didn’t allow his pistol to bulge through his jacket. 

Why It Stands Out To Us

This is another type of holster that is considered unique. But it makes concealed carry pretty interesting, to say the least. In fact, some security firms even encourage shoulder holsters or wearing holsters that are not considered hip holsters. This makes a potential assailant or attacker assume that security guards don’t carry so they are free and clear to cause trouble. But they’ll be shocked when they finally realize that they’ve been wrong all along. But nevertheless, this shoulder holster alone has proven itself to provide excellent concealability as it gives you superior durability and security better than any non-hip holster on the market. 

Obviously, this review would be incomplete if we didn't mention the very famous ‘James Bond’ style shoulder holster. No doubt this holster looks splendid and classy.

The entire shoulder holster is made up of 100% genuine leather, and the straps are adjustable. The holster features an adjustable retaining strap with Velcro so you can adjust it according to your convenience.

The holster works well with several guns other than the P238. So it might be a ‘one-for-all’ package for you. The other end of the holster features a magazine holder, which can also be detached and used with your belt separately.

The hoops on the padding of the holster make the pointing direction of the barrel adjustable. It can be adjusted so the barrel may face backward or downwards.

Who Would Use This Most?

If you work security or still want to conceal carry but the weather might be a bit much for your hip holster, then you’re going to need a holster that will fit you and your pistol perfectly. And since it’s made from leather, this just might be a holster that will last you through many uses be it year-round or during the colder months. Regardless, it’s reliable, sturdy, and will secure your pistol without creating any undue attention or making it look obvious that you carry. 

Bottom Line

The XCH Shoulder Holster is a must-have for those who want a holster that is other than your usual IWB or OWB types. If you are looking to make your concealed carry more creative and enough to throw off any potential assailants, this might be the holster that can stand out the best. Nine times out of ten, they’ll expect you to draw from your holster. Make a fool of themselves by drawing quickly from a different area of your body while keeping yourself protected. 

The Shoulder Holster is a good choice for people working in the private security industry or for people who like to open carry. The holster offers extra space for a magazine and is also adjustable for the barrel pointing direction. Not a bad choice for someone inclined towards these type of holsters.

Conclusion

The P238 is a small and compact firearm which is perfect for concealed carry. There are a ton of holsters on the market, and some of them differ from others based upon several qualities like material, design, locking mechanism, comfort, etc.

A good P238 holster must offer concealment, should be comfortable, have good retention and can´t wobble much.  Hope you´ll find the best holster in the above-mentioned reviews. 

Leave a Comment